Jerusalem, Israel - June 29, 2023 - A group of international journalists sat in a community center meeting room with large photos of Yasser Arafat and Mahmoud Abbas smiling down on them as the 80-year-old woman told her emotional story of her father's farm she remembered from childhood. Not one person asked to see a deed or document of her family's ownership of the farm. Nevertheless, her sad tale was accepted as true. Jewish homes were destroyed and families forced to move.

In 1892, when Jews denied accusations of eating the blood of Christian boys, the response was: “Can everybody be wrong and the Jews right?"

Professor Richard Landes was trained as a medievalist historian and taught at Boston University. In his heavily footnoted book, Can “The Whole World” Be Wrong? Lethal Journalism, Antisemitism, and Global Jihad,  Landes compares medieval events with the political and journalistic scene at the turn of the third millennium (2000-2003).  

He documents how a radical inability of Westerners to understand the medieval mentality that drives Global Jihad prompted a series of misguided reactions that have shaped our so-far turbulent century. The misreporting of the unfolding of events beginning in 2000, first with the “murder” of Muhammad al Durah,  the September 9, 2001 attacks in New York City and the Pentagon, and in 2002 the Jenin “massacre.”  There was no murder or massacre. How could reporters get it so wrong?

Walking away from a detailed presentation at a scenic overlook in Judea and Samaria describing illegal Arab construction in Area C, one man said to his two companions, "That was a very good presentation, but we're journalists and we know it's all lies."

At a recent conference in Norway, journalist Matti Friedman stated that European journalists see Israel as  a "morality story." Rather than a regular "news story," it's a "parable about power" and is not a daily news cycle of ups and downs. "Israel is closer to a sermon" and not like the Russia and Ukraine story, he added. Even the Abraham Accords were reported from a critical angle - arms.

The book is divided into three sections - Part One: Selective History of the Disastrous Early Aughts (2000-2003, Part Two: Key Players, and Part Three: Are We Really Going to Let This Happen (Again)?.

The glossary fills ten pages, beginning with "a Durah - an icon of hatred, launched by French-Israeli journalist; first blood libel of the twenty-first century" and ends with "Y2K Logic - Western infidels, especially Israelis, must take Muslims at their word..."

"Pallywood" - a term first used years ago in Landes' blog Augean Stables for faked Arab anti-Israeli media, has become common usage.  One of the many new words this reviewer found in the book was "Oneidophobia - dread of public disgrace can paralyze, can galvanize to anger/violence...Shame-Honor Culture."

Years of research and publications are quoted throughout the text of the 486-page book, and at the end there is a bibliography, a list of names, and a list of subjects.

The book was launched on February 21, 2023, at the Menachem Begin Heritage Center in Jerusalem, Israel, with a discussion of the book and the issues it raises. After Richard Landes spoke, the program included a panel with the former director general of the Ministry of Strategic Affairs and a leading expert on Israeli security and diplomatic strategy Yossi Kupperwasser; Adam Levick, from media monitoring organization CAMERA; and journalist and author of Londonistan, Melanie Phillips, moderated by Paul Gross of the Begin Center.

Can the whole world be wrong?  

Examples of lethal journalism, antisemitism, and global jihad can be found, not just in Israel. "We are in the fight of our lives, a fight for the civilization...our fight is with those who think truth and honor come from dead corpses and dominion...Choose life, however difficult," concludes Landes. 

Publisher: Academic Studies Press

PB ISBN: 9781644696415 534 pgs. , Price: $24.95,  

Digital ePub.: 9781644699942 Price: $24.95  

Pub Date: Dec. 2022