Stamford, CT - A former New York city councilman had strong words about lawbreakers during a panel discussion at one of the opening sessions at this year’s Agudah convention when asked to offer his thoughts on how members of the Jewish community are negatively stereotyped in the media.
Met Council CEO and executive director David Greenfield responded passionately to the question posed by Agudath Israel of American’s New Jersey director, Rabbi Avi Schnall, who expressed concern about the prevalence of headlines proclaiming unsubstantiated allegations of wrongdoings committed by Orthodox Jews.
Reflecting back on his time in the City Council, Greenfield shared that as chairman of the land use committee, he participated in one meeting where an official said that a project required a second look because it involved “one of those developers.” Questioning the statement, Greenfield said that it took him a moment to realize what he had just heard.
“It hit me as I was sitting there with my yarmulke and a beard that ‘one of those developers’ meant it was someone from the community,” explained Greenfield.
Acknowledging that minority bias does exist, Greenfield stressed the importance of fighting back against unfounded accusations before launching into a passionate speech on calling out those who flout the law.
“When someone is actually guilty, and we know they are guilty, and they’ve embarrassed the community, we should throw them out of our shuls, and we shouldn’t accept them in our communities, and we should send a very clear and straight message that that kind of behavior is unethical, it’s illegal, it goes against halacha and our hashkafa and who we are as Orthodox Jews,” said Greenfield.
Taking a public stance of shunning those who commit crimes would go a long way towards improving the Jewish community’s public image, explained Greenfield.
“When you see that happening, when the next time a guy comes into shul and he did all sorts of horrible things but he is going get shishi because he gives $10,000 a year to the shul, when you throw the bum out, that’s when you’ll start seeing the tide will change,” said Greenfield.
Lakewood Township Committee member Meir Lichteinstein suggested that the media’s appetite for stories that portray the Jewish community in a bad light could be a tactic to drive profits, gently chiding Greenfield for falling pretty to the media hype. But Greenfield refused to back down, saying that while there is no doubt that there is media bias against the Orthodox Jewish community, those who are guilty of committing serious crimes should face consequences within the community.
“In some cases where everyone agrees someone did something horrible and offensive and against Torah values and in my opinion that person should be thrown the heck out of the community,” said Greenfield.
Rabbi Schnall and the Agudah’s New York director of government relations, Rabbi Yeruchim Silber, broached the topic of repentance creating atonement for past misdeeds, prompting Greenfield to draw an emphatic parallel between those who steal and those who publicly desecrate Shabbos.
“I think if we are having an honest conversation once a year about the challenges of the community, if you’re asking me, one of the ways to fix that perception is that when that when someone is in fact a crook, or when someone is in fact a gonif, or when someone has in fact done something where he created a massive chilul Hashem where you open up the papers every single day and this guy is in the papers, don’t give him an aliyah,” said Greenfield, adding, “yes, you can quote me on that. I stand by that just as how if someone pulls up in a Ferrari in front of shul on Shabbos don’t give him an aliyah either.”
Greenfield also respectfully disagreed with Assemblyman-elect Simcha Eichenstein who suggested that how someone is treated when they walk into a synagogue is unrelated to the media’s portrayal of Orthodox Jews. Greenfield criticized the practice of wealthy individuals who have committed crimes being honored at dinners just because they have deep pockets.
“I think the media sees that and they say ‘are you being honest or are you not being honest?’” remarked Greenfield. “And they are rare exceptions and it is rare that it happens in the community, but when it happens we should set a firm line and say ‘those people do not represent our community,’ because they don’t.”