JERUSALEM (VINnews) — The 8th of Elul marks two significant historic events separated by thousands of years but sharing a common denominator: Gentiles destroying Jewish houses and setting them on fire.
In the year 70 C.E. after the destruction of the Second Temple, the Romans continued their siege on the upper city of Jerusalem, where the modern day Jewish and Armenian quarters are situated. It was the 8th of Elul when the Romans finally succeeded in conquering this section and set about burning it to the ground. Anyone who has visited the Burnt House in the old city of Jerusalem cannot fail to notice the carnage wrought by the Romans when they destroyed Jerusalem.
Fast forward nearly two thousand years to the year 2005. Israel agreed to unilaterally disengage and forcibly remove 25 flourishing communities in the Gush Katif region south of Gaza. Rather than leave the houses to the Arab enemies, Israel decided to raze them to the ground. However the thought of razing shuls and batei midrash was anathema to many Israelis. The Jewish nation had suffered so much destruction of houses of prayer at the hands of our enemies, especially during the Holocaust, that it was unthinkable that Jewish hands would be raised against these holy places. Yet this was what Arik Sharon, the mastermind of the disengagement, intended to do.
Attorney Gilad Corinaldi filed an urgent petition to the Supreme court requesting that the shuls should not be razed by the IDF. The petition included a letter from Rabbi Zalman Nehemia Goldberg which said that “it is preferable that the shuls should stay in their place. In order to prevent their desecration it would be right to place international inspectors to maintain the places and when the peace becomes stronger Jews could come and pray in those central shuls.”

Corinaldi says that Rabbi Goldberg’s letter had a significant effect on the Supreme court, whose judges respected Rabbi Goldberg as a senior member of the Higher Rabbinic court and this may have swayed the court to prevent the destruction of the shuls.
However eventually the shuls were destroyed by marauding Arabs from Gaza after the withdrawal of Israel and this occurred on the 8th of Elul, which once again became a day of destruction of Jewish buildings by gentiles. Some people even suggested making it a day of fast and mourning.
Corinaldi later wrote a book about the successful battle to save the Gush Katif shuls from being destroyed by Jews.